Three basic reasons:
-
Learning a brass instrument is complicated and challenging compared to traditional classroom instruments:
- Basic sound production on a brass instrument requires significant embouchure and respiratory system development (especially in comparison to the recorder).
- Unlike woodwinds, strings, and Orff instruments, where you can see the position of each note and how they relate to each other, brass instruments operate on the harmonic series (hidden from view) which requires development of aural skills and more precise pitch production.
- Adding valves, slides, and reading music notation to the above points creates layers of variables that can make teaching beginning brass in a whole-class setting extremely challenging.
- Most teachers assume that they cannot teach brass unless they have a brass background - that teaching brass requires specialized knowledge and training. It creates a self-perpetuating cycle: Since few teachers are exposed to brass in their formative years, few would feel capable of teaching it.
- Cost & upkeep: Brass instruments are expensive to purchase, costly to repair, and the regular maintenance to keep valves and slides in good working order can be significant, often eating up valuable instructional time.